Heretik Volume 1: Body of Accusations (2000)
Ownership: 1998 Mahl (CD). Liners from Guy LeBlanc detailing each track. Acquired in 1999.
Funny to watch my trajectory with FM, a band I couldn't be bothered with in my initial foray into progressive rock back in the 80s and 90s. Yes, I had heard all of their albums back in the day, since they were common then too. I had at least one friend insist that I should at least like the album I'm listening to right now, but I wasn't having any of it.
Now I'm a big fan of all their initial four albums. And, yes, Direct to Disc is certainly the most progressive oriented of the lot. There's also a strong electronic component here as well. Cameron Hawkins is completely unleashed here. Vocals are kept to a minimum, and there's no intent for securing a radio hit. In this way, I'm going to categorize the album different then their brethren.
You'd think an audiophile limited edition record, on a small label, would be worth serious dinero right? While certainly this title holds the most value, it's hardly a bank breaker. And for a limited edition, there sure are a lot of pressings out there. Making the premise faulty from the beginning. Ironically I found this for the cheapest price of them all, recently digging it out of a 25 cent bin. My entire FM LP collection cost me less than $5.
Ownership: 1978 Labyrinth (LP). Gatefold. Acquired in 2026.
4/6/26 (review)
Musically Surveillance is very much the sound of the aforementioned Black Noise combined with City of Fear. Each album takes baby steps to more commercial realms, but they're proggers at heart, keeping the music interesting throughout. Suddenly I've become a late-in-life fan of FM.
Ownership: 1979 Passport Canada (LP). Acquired in 2023.
10/27/23 (review)
Black Noise is an excellent example of proggy AOR music with fat sounding synthesizers, violin, and a strong rhythm section (Cameron Hawkins performs double duty on bass). Fits well in that unique Canadian niche of groups such as Saga, Dillinger, Klaatu, Avalon, etc... A couple of years ago I was pleasantly surprised by City of Fear, and so goes Black Noise.
Ownership: 1978 Visa (LP). Acquired in 2023.
10/22/23 (review)
This is just the kind of album I poo-pooed in my youth. Constantly pushed in my face as "prog", I tended to react negatively. Well it's not Yes, but it's definitely proggy. And over the years I've really been drawn to that late 70s "prog AOR" music. And these Canadians have a great thick sound. Many highlights can be found here. Very much in the Saga, Klaatu mold.
Ownership: 1980 Passport (LP). Gatefold. Acquired in 2021.
11/29/21 (review)
4/6/26 (new entry)
---12/14/09
Much was made at the time of release that True Myth's sole album was the first ever all digital recording from Canada. I guess it's ironic, then, that the album remains unissued in digital format. This is obviously a big budget affair, complete with a thick gatefold cover, lengthy liner notes, and a brilliant production. Musically, even though it's from Canada, it has much in common with the US Midwest prog rock scene of the mid 1970s. 1979 was a little late for an album like this, and there's the expected obvious commercial AOR moves. Excellent high energy piano work recalling Festa Mobile, for an obscure reference. A good album that is generally panned by the progressive rock community. But I have a soft spot for this kind of stuff and recommend it to those who like groups such as Ethos, Styx, and Sunblind Lion.
---3/2/26
That entry was for the CDRWL, and shortly thereafter, a CD appeared out of Japan on Belle Antique. The album now makes its debut on UMR.
Named for keyboardist and principle songwriter Tom Treumuth, the London, Ontario based band were blessed with a large budget. How successful album sales were would be anybody's guess, but there's plenty of supply in the used marketplace. I didn't mention it above, but once again Gentle Giant can be used as a reference here, a very common occurrence for the region. In reflection this album really should have made the big time. It has everything that was expected from the era, including great songs, production, and musicianship. Special mention goes to guitarist Tony Cook who lights it up on more than one occasion. Excellent mellotron on B1. In reflection, the album is more progressive rock oriented than I had realized before. All the short form tracks pack in a lot of ideas per bar.
Perhaps it was just too progressive for its own good, and there really isn't any notable hooks that linger after the listening session has stopped. Which is why novelty records tend to do better in real time, though they rarely age well. A3 was probably their best shot, sounding quite a bit like same era Supertramp. An impressive debut, but sadly it was to be their last. Though there's no doubt the band would have been forced to adapt to the upcoming New Wave trends or go underground. The latter option would be doubtful.
Ownership: 1979 Warner Bros. (LP). Gatefold. Multi page poster lyric and historical insert made to look like tractor feed printer paper. Acquired in 1992.
1992; 12/14/09 (review); 3/2/26 (update / new entry)
Lies To Live By was one of my earliest discoveries of non-English progressive rock. Found the LP at one of the Dallas record shows while still in college (likely the summer since I was in Lubbock otherwise, and I had intern earnings to spend). For whatever reason I have yet to document the album in any forum, so best to get on that.
I wasn't sure what to make of the music back in '86. It wasn't immediately likeable, at least for my tastes then. There was one exception, which I'll cover below. A couple of years later I traded it for something more to my liking, only to obtain it again (brand new as it turns out) in a collection buy in 1994. By then I had secured the CD, and wheeled and dealed a sweet return that I'm sure I still have today (did that a lot from '94-'96). A few years ago I paid handsomely for a super nice original, and that will be its resting place.
Today I hear the album as a bonafide progressive rock classic, so what was the original problem? For one, it does take a bit to get going. A1 and A3 are more in the folk rock vein, though A2 certainly introduces proggy concepts. Today I hear all three as excellent, as they are all subtlety progressive. It isn't until 'War Story' that The Spirit of Christmas gets into The Spirit of Progressive Rock. The way the track is structured, and the mellotron use, recalls the great Kestrel. The latter a band I wouldn't know for some years later. Not sure my brain was around any kind of AOR concepts at that time.
The major exception to my initial ennui was 'Factory'. This is Rush before Rush was Rush. Make sense? That is to say, what Rush became in the late 70s, not how they started. A mixture of hard rock and prog, the track moves in multiple directions with some dynamite guitar and tricky rhythms. A whole album in this style would have likely been labeled an all-time classic by just about everyone. Unfortunately it was the only highlight for me at the time, likely due to its heaviness.
This takes us to the 11:30 minute closer, for which I was expecting an epic closer. And didn't get it. From a flow perspective they probably should have flipped the two B-side songs for a stronger ending. I was younger and more impatient at age 21, so it wasn't what I was hoping. Today, knowing full well the contents throughout, I find it an excellent way to go out. It's more English sounding than North American, and demonstrates the maturity the band possessed at that time. And that was the end of the various incarnations of Christmas. Band leader Bob Bryden went in various directions after this, which he's taken the time to well document.
1986; 1995; 11/29/17; 2/23/26 (review)
Once owned both Christmas and Heritage. They were boots and I long sold them off. Need to revisit both at some point.
2/23/26 (new entry)
Drummer John Rutsey was not just a tagalong member, but rather he was one of the two founders (along with Alex Lifeson) and was a major part of their original sound. He wanted to stay the course with the driving hard rock the band had established a small reputation for. But Lifeson and Geddy Lee (nee Weinrib) wanted to add prog rock elements and go a different direction. Along with Rutsey's health problems, it was decided a change was needed. Auditions were held, and they selected brainiac Neil Peart as their new drummer and lyric writer. The die was cast.
As a listener, it helps to put your mind into the 1974 landscape (which I did last night resulting in a +1 listen). Wet T-Shirt night and jammin' guitars was the name of the game. The cheaper the beer - the better. More for the merrier, that is to say. In that light, the great tracks here are opener 'Finding My Way', 'What You're Doing', and 'Before and After'. Best of all is the track that Ms. Halper thought would appeal to Cleveland's hard working industrial base: 'Working Man'. This song would remain as the sole representative the band took forward for their live set from their debut. If you don't go in expecting 2112 or Hemispheres, and you like hard rock, then there's a good chance to you might really enjoy Rush's debut.
Ownership: 1976 Mercury (LP)On Moving Pictures, Rush were clearly moving away from their 70s prog rock roots and entering the 80s decade. In retrospect, they were pioneers, a band with the foresight and wisdom to predict the mood and whim of the fans. It's Side 1 that everyone knows from the album - 'Tom Sawyer', 'Red Barchetta', and 'Limelight' being instant radio hits. Ones you still hear to this day everywhere. A close study reveals a lot of invention and thought, wrapped around a commercial sensibility the band had lacked prior. The move to synthesizers proved to be prescient. "ygrek ygrek zed" (the Toronto airport of course) was the one track that took me in instantly, and recalled my fave 'La Villa Strangiato' from the beginning of my Rush journey. But in compact form, like everything else on the album So in recent listens (twice in three years - amazing regularity!), it's been side 2 that requires my focus, as I rarely remember anything about it. Ironically it's the more progressive rock oriented side and has aged incredibly well for me.
I still have the ticket stub of the concert I saw in April 1981 at Reunion Arena in Dallas (funny that it was still a new arena then. Been out of service for over 18 years now), which adds more nostalgia points to the formula.
Nightwinds were a Canadian prog band from the late 70s who recorded an album but didn't get a chance to release it, and off into the netherworld the group went. Rescued by The Laser's Edge, it would be 12 years (recent by archival standards) before the album made its debut. Ironically its arrival came a bit late for me and my running set of the era. We were all "Genesis'd out" by then. One of us bought the album and we all sampled it, but another band going down the Gabriel-era Genesis road was not what we were looking for at the time. Back then we bought just about every prog album that was released, but I decided against this title. By 1991 I was deep diving all over the world looking for the best prog albums ever made or were being made. Nightwinds wasn't where my dollars were going. Besides I was still mostly an "LP only" guy. Mostly from a financial perspective rather than for audiophile reasons.
It wasn't until 2009 that I finally sat down and heard the album all the way through. By then I was open to hear any good album, as my exhaustive searching for prog nirvana had reached its logical conclusion (not that I had heard everything, just the quest had leveled off). And yea, Nightwinds is really good actually. By that time Nightwinds was years out of print, and copies were selling for top dollar. It's OK, I'll wait.
And here we are 16 years later from that event and I've finally secured the CD at a reasonable price. One of those extremely rare times (these days) where the album arrived in the mail, and I popped it into the changer immediately (and listened to it twice in a row, another anomaly). That's exactly how I used to do it back in 1991. Not stacks of albums that sit waiting for their day on the turntable or in the player. So it's fitting to transport myself back to the era in which this was released.
So what of this music that Nightwinds plays? Would you believe it reminds me of Genesis? Haha. Of course it does. Actually it reminds me most of Florida's Babylon, another band that was ahead of the neo-prog curve by about three years. And that's the storyline here - it's a more compact and accessible form of early Genesis, just as IQ, Pallas, Marillion and the rest of them would bring forward in the 80s. Germany had other like-minded groups operating in similar fashion such as Neuschwanstein, Sirius, Ivory, Touch, and others. Take Wind and Wuthering, add Peter Gabriel back in, and modernize the sound. There's certainly nods to same era Rush and Saga, both hailing from Ontario and no doubt an influence here. But Nightwinds aren't as hard rocking as Rush nor as modern as Saga. Interesting to note that bassist Mike Gingrich came from the excellent Amish, one of my CDRWL staples.
In reflection, the late 80s and early 90s were an exciting time to be a hardcore progressive rock fan, which I most certainly was (and still the case - despite my constant forays into other genres). Back then new bands were sprouting everywhere, and the possibilities seemed endless. Plus I had a paying job (pennies really but happy to have it, and paved the road for the future), was still a single lad in my 20s, and allocated an inordinate amount of money to my hobby. That an album like Nightwinds was met with a yawn indicates the sheer amount of quality new product available to us at the time. Saturation was to come. But not yet.
Ownership: 1991 Laser's Edge (CD). Lyric booklet.
2009 (first listen); 5/5/25 (review / new entry)
Even if I had heard it, my tastes have changed to really appreciating this type of hard rock. The inauspicious openers are party rockin' bar n' roll. No thanks. After that though, you'll hear influences such as Pink Floyd and Jimi Hendrix (Frank Marino probably). But perhaps most relevant is fellow Toronto heroes Rush. By the end of each side, Triumph shows a proggy heritage, with both 'Street Fighter' and 'The Blinding Light Show' being the highlights. Plenty of synthesizer on here too. It's time for me to revisit all of the Triumph works. I suspect my viewpoint will be far more favorable than it was in the 80s.
Ownership: 1976 Attic (LP). Blue label original.6/7/24 (review)
6/8/24 (new entry)
1992 (first acquired); 6/28/24 (review)
Parallel to this is the music appreciation of these albums. I had been told - and I think many experienced this as well - that Saga started as a prog band. That they weren't near as commercial as they were to become. Well hot damn! I already really enjoyed Worlds Apart (more now than back then), so these must be magnificent. Ehh... no. Not no in that they aren't very good, but no in that they aren't any different. Which is the great storyline here. For 1978, Saga was predicting the future of music by at least four years. This isn't the Midwest pomp of Styx or Kansas, but rather the global AOR / MTV sound of 1982. Way ahead of their time, Saga were already using punchy guitar lines and synthesizers crammed into compact radio friendly tunes. And they were always good at adding a touch of sophistication to their compositions, going far beyond pandering to the masses. Which is their secret sauce and makes them so endearing all these years later. There's even a dash of Gentle Giant especially when you consider the counterpoint vocal lines. The verdict? This is exactly what I'd hoped to hear. When I first heard them in the late 80s I was mightily disappointed, mainly due to the poor expectation setting. Had I known that these early albums were very similar, I probably would have passed back then. But now I hear it as one more great album in their repertoire.
Ownership: 1978 Polydor (LP). Lyric inner. 3/25/23 (review)9//82; 7/14/14; 2/12/22 (review)
Not the most compelling notes I've ever penned. But last night's listen confirmed the higher grade. So what is the magic here? The review above does a decent job of capturing side 1. It's side 2 that we need to focus on. Sounding every bit like Rush, before Rush was Rush, you know what I mean? Haha - that is, Toronto's A Foot in Coldwater is predicting Caress of Steel, not the self-titled 1974 album. Also, if you can compartmentalize this, listen to All Around Us with a singles 45 mentality. There's some really good hard psych material here too, a throwback to a fuzzier time. This album looks both forward and to the past. The back cover indicates good times AOR. They fooled us all.
I'll be the first to admit I'm not the world's biggest "psych" fan. I absolutely adore psychedelic influences in my progressive rock, but actual psych rock tends to be too straight for me in most instances, and rarely lives up to the genre name. But when an album is truly psychedelic in both sound, and composition, then I take notice. Nucleus is that album. In fact, at times it's a bit too disjointed to get into. It's really a strange phenomena they have going here. They seem to be jamming, but in odd time signatures ---- for each member. Perhaps it's pure incompetence, and no one band member can keep up with the other. Maybe. But I doubt it. It sounds intentional to me. It's downright disorienting at times. Which, almost by definition, is psychedelic. There's some incredible Hammond organ and acid guitar on here, with all sorts of screamed, distant, and... well... melodic vocals. Damn, this album is just flat out cool honestly.
---12/22/22
That remains my understanding of this most unique album. Because of this creativity, I bumped it a +1 into the masterpiece category. As the years ago by, it's albums like this that standout as truly interesting. I listened to it twice in a row and I couldn't really pinpoint what they were doing. That's a plus. And the sound is delicious, all the right textures. A stellar album.
Ownership: 1969 Mainstream (LP)8/20/22 (new entry)
Ownership: LP: 2005 RecordPlex. 2 LPs in a single sleeve (copy #103/500). 3 sides of music with one side blank. Recent online acquisition. From a documentary standpoint, not the best archival release I've ever seen, that for sure. There's an insert, but it lacks detail. And I've never been a big fan of stuffing 2 LPs into a single sleeve. That reeks of the cheapo 80s. Reminds me of Metallica's In Justice For All, the only LP by them I actually replaced with a CD (to no regrets). But what matters most is the music and the sound quality, and for this, it's well worth it. This is one of those albums where the LP proved easier to get than the CD. As long as this website stays up, you can read more about Fable.
Artifacts (1994) Steve Roach has had an incredibly prolific career, releasing 100's of albums (Discogs lists a total of 257, which is in...