2025 Prog Journal

Transatlantic - SMPTe. 2000 InsideOut (CD). Transatlantic were one of those prog supergroups that were quite popular in the late 90s and throughout the 2000 decade. This was their debut and they still get together on occasion and release new material.  I never bothered with any of these acts real time, so the thrift shop is coming in real handy to see what I missed. This collective brings key players from Dream Theater, Marillion, Spock's Beard, and The Flower Kings / Kaipa. So the band moniker is accurate. Not surprisingly the album opens up with a six part, 31 minute opus. They were absolutely going for prog street cred here. Opening impressions is that one hears retro prog, especially classic Yes, mixed in with the modern variation of said sound. Spock's Beard and The Flower Kings do seem to be the leading lights if looking for quick comparisons. Instrumentally the music is fantastic. Some of the vocals sections drag, especially when in chorus mode. The latter being the Neil Morse annoyance contribution. It would be easy to be cynical about such a release, especially coming from a hardcore underground perspective. But that's not fair at all, as these guys put together a very fine, professional release. One that clearly was carefully composed, rehearsed, and recorded. That doesn't mean this album is for me, however. There's something very contrived about it, and lacks that emotional and creative spark we get from the amateurs. But for those who are into "names", you really can't go wrong here. (10/23)

Family - Anyway. 1971 United Artists (LP). The story goes that Family weren't satisfied with their last studio album - failing to capture the band at their finest (a familiar argument). So for Anyway they split the album as half live and half studio even though it's all new material. The live side isn't recorded very well so that doesn't help. The other issue here is the tracks sort of fly by without notice. There's really not much that stands out - whether it's a memorable tune or a mind bending instrumental passage. I'm sticking Anyway in the prog section as I'm not really sure where else to put them. Maybe classic rock would have been better, though that's not their reputation. On the plus side, this album did reignite my interest in the band. I do have a couple of their albums already on CD, and now I picked up one of their recognized classics on LP. A feature may be coming soon (nope) (6/16).

*Steve Hackett - Clocks. 1979 Charisma (EP). The title track, coming from Spectral Mornings, is a super version featuring Novatron. You'll recognize many of the Genesis themes on 'Acoustic Set' utilizing only acoustic guitar and flute, and which seemingly has as much applause as music. 'Tigermoth' also comes from Spectral Mornings and is another fantastic rendition with heavy Moog, flute, and electric guitar. The last hurrah for Genesis and prog music. Have to keep this. Oh great - EP's as large as LPs and looking to downsize. (2/2)

Discus - ...Tot Licht! 2003 Gohan (CD). Collection revisit. Have you ever wondered what it would be like if you combined prog metal, avant prog, and 80s Japanese symphonic prog with female vocals? Yea, I hadn't really given that one much thought either. But if I did, Discus' second album would be the answer. Discus demonstrates a complete lack of focus and decides to give you as much progressive rock ideas as they can come up with on the fly. Genre hopping within the prog world was somewhat popular in the 2000s, and Indonesia's Discus were one of the leading lights, obscure as they may have been (though they did play live in North Carolina). Interesting that they also appear to be very religious, both Christian and Muslim together. In any case, a fascinating listen, but I don't feel albums like this. A familiar theme: Appreciation doesn't always translate to excitement. This version has a six minute bonus track. (1/6)

* - keeping for the collection

2025 X-Wave Journal Vol. 1

*Ministry - With Sympathy. 1983 Arista (MC). I originally obtained this on LP with the 2019 80's collection buy but decided to take the profit, even though I had a solid rating for it. This relisten resulted in a +1, so I'll keep the next LP I find (if I find it...). To be honest even after that first listen some six years ago, I thought this was a different Ministry from the band I knew from the late 80s and early 90s. In fact I thought this band was British and then broke up. Haha. My confusion is common of course. Starting out in Chicago, Ministry hopped on (or was pushed on depending on your source of truth) the synthpop bandwagon. Apparently the duo's heart turned dark and they created a new world for themselves - that of industrial metal. A very angry music indeed. You would never know that by the jolly and upbeat tones of With Sympathy. The interesting thing about Ministry, in retrospect, is just how good they were at New Wave music. It's far more complex and involved than your garden variety dance pop group. A fascinating beginning to a fascinating band. I'm sure at some point I will find their metal albums, one of which I owned on CD many years ago but sold off. (Feb)

Steve Hackett - A Doll That's Made in Japan / Just the Bones. 1984 Lamborghini (12" single). At 13 minutes it's really an EP length. As with all of Hackett's Genesis contemporaries - all obvious prog guys - this single belongs to 80s music. A) side is a mix of Japanese music (novelty level), glossy 80s with synthesizers and digital drums, and a nice guitar solo. B) side is similar but leaves off the Japanese angle. Not so bad really, just such a disappointment that none of the Genesis guys would acknowledge their heritage during the 80s. (Feb)

Modern English - Ricochet Days. 1984 Sire (MC). Here's a good test of a band I revere from a nostalgic perspective (After the Snow, an LP I own), who released Ricochet Days during that strike zone (early 80s), but I don't recognize anything from it. Does it hold up and is it collection worthy? Yes and no. For example A3 and B2 are rewrites of 'I Melt With You' and there's this persistent feeling that there isn't much more under the blanket from a creative viewpoint. Elsewhere there's a distinctive turn towards The Beatles baroque psych pop of 1966-67. Englishness as it were, living up to their name at least. All of which is inoffensive but not inspiring either. A reasonable follow-up to their classic work, yet lacking in something. Authenticity perhaps? I like it but won't keep it. (Feb)

*Missing Persons - Spring Session M. 1982 Capitol (MC). I've had this on vinyl before but didn't take notes. Thinking it was part of that 2019 80's buy. I did decide to keep their next effort Rhyme & Reason. So let's get a fresh take on their debut full-length. Right away I notice a more aggressive hard rock guitar attack throughout, something they most certainly softened on subsequent releases. These guys were from the Zappa camp, so musicianship was not an afterthought. As I continue to say (too often, just in this post alone), these 80s albums work best when I get a nostalgia pull, especially the early part of the decade while still in high school. And there's a few tracks here that bring back that unique period of time. Yea, I'm keeping this, and like with A-ha below, will replace it with the LP whenever I find it in the wilds (this one still goes for cheap). (Feb)

Madonna - True Blue. 1986 Sire (Canada) (MC). I was pleasantly surprised at how much I enjoyed the first two Madonna's. I was able to appreciate both the nostalgia aspect as well as her artistic abilities from an objective standpoint, now that we're 40 years on from the lightning rod opinions that surrounded her in the early 80s. By the time of True Blue, my nostalgia meter falls off (just in general this is the case), as by then I was deep diving into the European prog underground of the 70s, and not paying much attention to contemporary pop culture. In addition, it's clear the creative well is running dry for Ms. Ciccone. 'Papa Don't Preach' and 'La Isla Bonita" are the two tracks I recognize from here and both I enjoy. Much of the others (not all) sound like filler to support the next tour. I'm interested in hearing her other albums just to see what triggers. Remember that Mrs. UMR was a big fan when we were newly married (hard to believe that was 28 years ago), and she owned a Best Of, which we listened to often in the car on road trips. Today she could care less about Madonna, but I'm still intrigued. Funny how that works. I also found a near perfect LP copy late last year at a thrift shop, and now I can safely move that to the record show boxes. (Jan)

*A-ha - Hunting High and Low. 1985 Warner Bros. (Canada) (MC). Well... finally. Despite buying multiple 80s collections and thrift shop dumps in the last six years, I have yet to run into a single A-ha album - in any format. I know this Norwegian group better from their super obscure 60s retro band Bridges (which doesn't even get mentioned in their Wikipedia entry) than I do for their obvious hit records. First track is 'Take on Me', which is mid-80s MTV college bullseye material right there. This is exactly the kind of synth pop I enjoy. Energetic, danceable (not that I'm doing that), and melodic. As I often say, these albums tend to work for me when there's a nostalgia play, and that's what we get with Hunting High and Low. I'll hold onto this tape until I eventually find their LP. (Jan)

Bangles. 1983 Faulty (MC). Before the gals became a hit sensation, they released a single and an EP on private and small labels. Known originally as The Bangs, they shifted on this EP to simply Bangles (one can imagine the double entendre problem). The music here is different than what they were to become. A mid to late 60s garage girl styled group sound emerges. RYM refers to this 80s movement out of Los Angeles as Paisley Underground. Not bad at all. (Jan)

Depeche Mode - Songs of Faith and Devotion. 1993 Sire (CD). This album is the highly rated follow-up to their lauded classic Violator. Even for a non-fan like me, I kept that CD. But this title didn't stir up much reaction. Whereas I saw Violator as the bookend of the synth wave movement, I hear Songs of Faith and Devotion as a tired retread of ideas with a purposeful move to alternative rock, which is definitely not my music of choice. Given its popularity with the general public, I just have to accept it's good for the style and leave it at that. (Jan)

Camouflage - Greyscale. 2015 Bureau B (CD). Just like with Surface 10 that is on the DiN label, there's no way I'm passing up anything on Bureau B for a couple of bucks. I had no idea who Camouflage were, but they apparently were legends from the synth-pop scene in Germany going back to the 80s (of course). And that's exactly how I heard this album without any pre-conceived notions. In fact I just pushed it into my car CD changer without even looking at it, and had forgotten they were on Bureau B, trying to figure out why I bought it in the first place. The label's description is telling: "Their music brilliantly combined the icy coolness of Kraftwerk, the pop of OMD and the melancholy gloom of Depeche Mode.". The latter group is what entered my mind first, and funny to see that I just covered OMD. In fact, I think I did find these together last year at the same shop. The vocal tracks are too much of the original scene, as noted below, and that only works with me if the recording is from that era. The instrumentals, however, are more exciting, including one Krautrock styled flute driven number. Much better than OMD's attempt below, but a long way from collection shelf space. (Jan)

OMD - The Punishment of Luxury. 2017 White Noise (CD). I didn't even realize these guys were around much past the 80s. And after hearing this CD, they haven't really moved on from the synth pop style. Sounds dogeared to me. Not quite sure how you can advance this style too much, though I guess I could say the same thing about straight ahead thrash metal. Anyway, nothing here for me to hold onto. Music like this only works for me if it's from the 80s, and as a pure nostalgia play. (Jan)

* - Keeping for the collection