Now that I've relistened to the first two Satin Whale albums on CD, I was curious how the next three would go since I've never heard them prior. I was told they were more commercial and not so interesting, which is why I never bothered prior. As noted many times, my interest in proggy AOR has gone up considerably so I figure I might be a good candidate to really enjoy this album. Especially when you consider that Satin Whale displayed a strong knack for melody even on their two acclaimed prog albums. So was I pleased? Yes and no. There are some great moments here, especially on the instrumental 'Maree' which would have fit perfectly on Lost Mankind. Flute remains a key part of their sound palette, and adds more contrast to their overall sound. The opening couple of songs are off putting at first, as the sound is too foreign for Satin Whale. Like they're trying too hard to be commercial when they don't need to. I listened to the album three times straight and the familiarity helped me appreciate more what they were trying to accomplish. There's plenty of progressive rock sequences mixed in with what appears to be straightforward compositions. At least on As a Keepsake, Satin Whale didn't convince me they were a top tier AOR candidate, but I wasn't disappointed either.
Ownership: 2023 Made in Germany (The Studio Albums). 5xCD. Jewel case. Details on the Desert Places post.
3/28/24 (first listen/new review)
No comments:
Post a Comment