Masque (1975)
Song for America (1975)
When I first got into music via FM radio in 1977, Kansas was not a favorite of mine. Time and place plays a major role in one's development, and this includes music appreciation. Point of Know Return was extremely popular upon release, and the title track and 'Dust in the Wind' were played incessantly. Neither swayed me much back then. I wasn't annoyed, but it was tiresome. I did like 'Carry on Wayward Son' from their previous Leftoverture album, but that was a whole year old! lol. Progressive rock was still a few years away for me and their brand of AOR wasn't that appealing either. A high school buddy, he himself a musician, was a huge Kansas fan. I credit him for encouraging me to hear them differently, especially their early albums. And by late high school I was already immersing into progressive rock anyway. It wasn't until college that I eventually picked up their albums through, ironically, Point Of Know Return. And to this day, those albums they released while I was actually in high school (1979-1983) had no impact on me. That is to say at the point I was introduced to the band is also where they declined. Not really an uncommon story when you consider that I got going in the late 70s just at that point where bands were moving (forcefully or willingly) to more commercial waters. It really wasn't until the 2000s that my appreciation for Kansas began to accelerate. Today I consider them something as magical, a group who represented what American progressive rock could have been. They were about the only one that transcended to the major labels and had blockbuster radio hits. And many of us know by now just how many great bands there were in this country, but most didn't even get a chance to record, and those that did were released in tiny numbers. This blog is full of those albums and archival releases.
Today, the album I'm reviewing here, along with the aforementioned Point Of Know Return and Leftoverture, is considered their best album. That was not the case in 1977, no way and no how. Perhaps the latter two, but Song for America? It was as relevant as Foxtrot was to And Then There Were Three. Like I said: Time and Place.
Song For America is arguably their most progressive album, at least as we define the term today. Like everyone else in the States, Kansas took as a blueprint all the major UK prog bands, and then added those regional qualities that makes the subgenre so exciting to explore all these years later. Ten minute title tracks and the 12 minute 'Incomudro - Hymn to the Atman' was just not something many American bands had a chance to record. For Columbia no less. And there's really no duff tracks to hedge their bet either. Kansas were all in for prog rock, and their legacy will only continue to grow because of it. The younger generations, who do not have the baggage of the era, can listen more objectively and hear Song for America as it was intended. It's also worth mentioning that Kansas could also be considered a hard rock band, and had they trimmed the complexity level, they would have been top of class in the Midwestern hard rock sweepstakes. And local competition was even more fierce in that field back then.
Interesting to see the photos of the band. Their look was "of the era". Had they tried to break in during the 80s, they never would have gotten in the club door, much less recording time at a major studio. Three of the guys are decidedly overweight, Livgren looks like a sad old dog, with only Walsh and Ehart appearing telegenic (maybe). Metallica, Nirvana, and the rest of them were able to erase that stain for the 90s and beyond, but it's unfortunate that the 80s were so superficial in that way. How many great bands never got anywhere because of their appearance? Of course you could say that about a lot of things outside of music too.
The CD adds a single edit of the title cut plus a live rendition of 'Down the Road', neither offering up any revelations.
1975 Kirshner (LP)
2014 Friday (LP). Gatefold.
1985 (first acquired); 8/11/12; 9/22/25 (review)
Drastic Measures (1983)
I'll be spinning up a Kansas page eventually (done) but I don't want to start here. As the years have passed by, my admiration for Kansas has gone considerably up to the point where they've become one of my favorite bands. Their story is remarkable and what they were able to accomplish in a very hostile American commercial market is nothing short of incredible. Something I would not have understood when they were still relevant in the late 70s. But even they couldn't stop the tide that was to be the 80s. Generally considered their worst album, Drastic Measures sees Kansas try very hard to be in the same league as Journey, Boston, and REO Speedwagon. But it's just not for them. The group is only two thirds of the classic lineup, and even they were close to splitting up. The ride was over. Objectively speaking, Drastic Measures is no better or worse than many of the bands operating in the same tight space that was the 1983 AOR landscape. Interesting to note that this album was released in July of 1983. One month later was Metallica's Kill 'em All. The music world was a changin' fast.
Source: 1983 CBS Associated (LP)
5/7/25 (review)
Other albums I own and need to review: Kansas (1974); Leftoverture; Point of Know Return; Power; In the Spirit of Things; Freaks of Nature; Always Never the Same; Somewhere to Elsewhere; The Prelude Implicit; Early Recordings From Kansas (Proto-Kaw)
Other albums once owned: Monolith; Audio-Visions; Vinyl Confessions
9/22/25 (new entry)
No comments:
Post a Comment