Of course when you get a bunch of Dream Theater guys in a room, and they decide to eschew vocals, then you can expect one prominent feature: Wank. They have that reputation even on the DT albums, and it's absolutely fair. The trouble with wank is it's entirely unnecessary. It's a form of insecurity I think. "Look at how many notes I can play per second?" To me it's like a guitarist and keyboardist's version of the drum solo. Unless you are a budding musician learning how to play, the discerning listener is not going to be too impressed. When I first bought LTE 20 years ago, wankery was the lasting impression, and I quickly sold it off into the marketplace. Today a copy walks in the door - for about 10 cents - and hey let's give this one a serious listen since it's here.
The truth of the matter is Liquid Tension Experiment's debut is not just about instrumental show-off, but rather they did manage to write a few good tunes in the process. Which is pretty impressive considering the easy-out would have been to provide just the opposite. Perhaps Levin's influence looms large here, or the others had more to say than chromatic scale practice.
The reality is this album barely has any heavy metal at all, and is more rooted in jazz fusion and even jammy blues rock. The guitar solos - when not wanking - have an almost psychedelic feel to them.
The album could have stopped after 'Freedom of Speech', and would have scored a 4.0 in my book. The opener is excellent throughout, mixing the heavy with the melodic. 'Osmosis' sounds like an instrumental version of early 80s King Crimson - or even 80's Jade Warrior (bet you didn't see that coming!). 'Kindred Spirits' reminds me of the best of the 80's and 90's fusion albums, and again features some fine melodies.
Then they begin to run out of ideas and start to rely only on instrumental dexterity. 'Three Minute Warning' - and even the ensemble state it's self-indulgent - looks like a recipe for disaster. But it's not so bad really, especially the first 2 parts that are more like a good blues rock jam than a boring practice session. And then they lose it at the end... Pity that.
Overall much - much - better than I remembered, and well worth a concentrated listen. Should have been even better. But the insecurities got the best of them. I never did hear the second one. Maybe I'll pay double and get that one for 20 cents.
12/18/18 (new entry)