As with Magic is a Child, I hadn't actually
heard Down to Earth until now. Or I probably did in snippets and walked
away in disgust. This is exactly the type of album that would not have
appealed to me at age 21, or 31, maybe even 41. But at 51, I hear it in a
different way. Managing expectations is everything, and it's not
unreasonable for someone to approach this expecting to hear the sounds
of the album before (Remember the Future) or after (Recycled). In fact,
the latter album probably has more to do with the negative impression in
modern times, since it was rare for a band to make a "comeback" like
that in the 1970s. Just about every progressive rock band found their
way to commercialism over time. 1974 was perhaps a bit early to jump the
shark as it were, but in retrospect this album was actually ahead of
its time, though I'm sure audiences back then were quite baffled by it.
So in the end, had the band renamed themselves Ratken for this album, it
probably would have been received better.
And after hearing it
intently, I was quite surprised at how progressive it actually is. It's
tighter and doesn't possess the long stretches of progressive space rock
(or classic Kosmische Krautrock like the debut), so on the surface it
seems less complex. 'Nelly the Elephant' is startling in that it sounds
more like a horn rock track from 1970. It reminded me of the UK band The
Greatest Show on Earth actually (circus themes?). 'Early Morning Clown'
wouldn't be out of place on a Jonesy or Fruupp album. And 'That's Life' sounds like an outtake from Yes' Fragile session. In fact, only the
relatively dull song 'Little Boy' ended up being a slight
disappointment. This is a very good album to my ears, and I suspect will
always be misunderstood. I can see I'm of the minority opinion on this
one. OK, fair enough.
Ownership: LP: 1974 Bacillus. Gatefold. Quad. Recent acquisition from a Denver record store (2022). The above review came from the Japanese CD that I've since parted with.
1/23/16 (first listen / review / new entry); 8/5/23
No comments:
Post a Comment