Blue Oyster Cult were one of the very first bands I got into at the tender age of 13, much to the chagrin of my religious mother who didn't understand the allegory (not that I did either at the time, I just liked the music). Their material has held up well, and I own most of their classic albums. More updates will come eventually.
Mirrors was the first new studio album from Blue Oyster Cult after I had become a fan. Since my collection was still very small at the time, I found plenty to enjoy on the album. It wasn't really what I was looking for at the time, but I could explain it away. As more and more titles entered the household, Mirrors eventually became superfluous and I traded it off. Other than albums starting after The Revolution by Night, Mirrors was also the only classic era studio BOC I didn't have in the current collection. Found a minty one recently for cheap, so let's dig in for the first time in probably 40 years. It certainly isn't as bad as the low rating I had on it, though one can understand the disappointment. I was hardly alone in my assessment, and Mirrors remains their lowest rated album until the aforementioned Revolution album (according to RYM). Side 2 is the better half, and most of it is enjoyable. The first side isn't a total loss, though one wonders how they arrived at the suggestion that the title song was one of the treasures of the album. In any case, the one track here that is a fan favorite - and the one I loved at age 14 - is most certainly 'The Vigil'. It's really too bad BOC didn't pursue more of their proggy ambitions. They dabbled with it early in their career, and would later reference the genre every once in a blue moon. 'The Vigil' is one of the best tracks in their canon of work. Buck Dharma was at another level when penning this composition. It truly stands out on an album such as Mirrors, given that the rest of it is mostly commercial oriented. I wouldn't keep this album under normal circumstances, but the nostalgia pull here is huge.
Ownership: 1979 Columbia (LP)
1979 (first listen); 4/2/25 (review)
Blue Oyster Cult's 4th album Agents of Fortune is where I first started with the band. If memory serves, Spectres was already out, but once I saw 'Don't Fear the Reaper' on the back cover at the local K-Mart, then I decided to fork over my hard earned lawnmowing money on the album. I was 13 years old and with my mom (not like I was driving yet), and she wasn't too keen on me buying it due to the Tarot imagery, but she relented. To this day, I still think Reaper is a 5 star track despite having heard it countless times over a 47+ year period. That's how good it is. And it's certainly the highlight of Agents of Fortune, though it would be for almost any traditional song based album. The only other "known" track here is 'ETI' a rather heavy piece for its era, and signals their next big hit with 'Godzilla'. B2 is the other harder rocking cut, one I've always been fond of. The other seven songs are geared towards melodic AOR, something they proved to be adept at on Secret Treaties, though it was presented in a more progressive form on that album. B3 and B4 in particular are very touching. I like the opening track as well, seemingly more like a mid-album cut. Strange beginning I think. I can do without A2 which sounds like the Stones, never a good plan. The side closers are lackluster as well. The end summary is that Agents of Fortune is a good album, somewhere in the middle of their canon, but not extraordinary. Lost opportunity because one of the tracks is just that - extraordinary.
Ownership: 1976 Columbia (LP)
1978 (first listen); 6/21/20; 2/14/25 (review)
Hard Rock Live Cleveland (2014 / 2020)
Quite an elaborate package with a double digipak and three discs. At this stage, BOC is really Eric Bloom and Buck Dharma with a touring band. And these guys have lost their ability to sing in harmony, one of their trademarks. It's nice to hear great songs that are under performed such as 'Golden Age of Leather', 'The Vigil', and 'Black Blade'. But they just ain't got it anymore. Weak sound and out of tune vocals. Fans seem to love it. I personally go back with BOC to 1978, as they were one of my first favorite groups. No blinders for me though.
Source: 2020 Frontiers (2xCD + DVD)
1/15/25 (review)
Fire of Unknown Origin (1981)
Another one of those albums I bought new real time, got tired of, and sold by the early 90s. From a cover perspective, it's very clear that BOC were moving as far away from Mirrors as fast as possible. A classic of its kind. The music is easily identifiable as Blue Oyster Cult and it's not that much of a risk taker. Much was made of the Joan Crawford song in its era, but it's not going to change your world. The whole album screams early 80s hard rock, plain and simple. There's nothing that sticks with you for days like, say, 'Subhuman'. 'Burnin' For You', which was the big hit, may also be the album's best track.
Ownership: 1981 Columbia (LP)
1981 (first listen); 7/27/13; 1/9/23 (review)
The Revolution By Night (1983)
I first heard this album on my winter break from college in 1983. It was relatively new then. It was the same time period that I picked up Savatage's Sirens and Manilla Road's Crystal Logic. A friend swore it was great, but as you might imagine, I had completely moved away from poppy hard rock such as BOC by that time. I thought it was terrible and maintained a low rating for the next 40 years almost. With this era of the 80s in my lens, now is a good time to repurchase the album from a local store. Well... yea, I can certainly see why I thought nothing of it when I was 18. It is lightweight and it is poppy. Which doesn't translate to terrible like it once did. I did recognize the opener 'Take it Away', but nothing else, 'Veins' is really nice and one gets to hear Randy Jackson (American Idol of course...) play a mean bass on the lengthy 'Shooting Shark'. Side 2 is mostly solid hard rock as well. Other interesting guests are Larry Fast (Synergy) and Aldo Nova, a star in his own right not long before.
Ownership: 1983 Columbia (LP)
1983 (first listen); 3/4/22 (review)
Extraterrestrial Live (1982)
The first live album I ever bought was On Your Feet Or On Your Knees, which became a personal favorite when I was 14. To this day, it remains one my top live albums in the collection. By the time ETL came out, I was already tiring of BOC, and this live album seemed perfunctory. I had seen the band live around this time, and modern reviews are generally very positive, so I plucked down near-retail dollars to buy this used copy. Nope, looks like my 17 year old brain knew better. The key to On Your Feet is the improvisational and energy quotient, both missing from ETL. Obviously seeing them live was a different positive experience, but it isn't captured here. It's a run through of all their hits, and every album has at least one representative including even their least successful Mirrors album. The only cover song is Roadhouse Blues, the Doors chestnut that was overdone in those days. I don't think it's a very good song to begin with, and might be my least favorite Doors hit. Oh well, not every nostalgic pull is going to work out.
Source: 1982 Columbia (2xLP)
2/18/22 (review)
Secret Treaties (1974)
The last of the "Black and White" trilogy of albums, Secret Treaties ups the ante on just about everything. Considered by many to be their most thoughtful and challenging album, lyrically Blue Oyster Cult were living in a surreal, but parallel, universe. Even tracks that are essentially boogie rockers receive mid track breaks that belong more to progressive rock - or later in the heavy metal genre considering the mid song riff change. 'Subhuman' is melancholy on a plate with a killer underlying riff. 'Astronomy' is about as progressive as BOC will ever get, always pulling back instinctively knowing their audience are there to rock and roll. Buck Dharma has a very recognizable guitar style. Had he chosen a route similar to Santana, his name would be far more known today as a soloist rather than band member.
The CD adds five bonus tracks. Three of these were recorded during the Secret Treaties sessions but left off due to time constraints. Revisiting these, it appears the band / label made the right choice as they are more straightforward than the album proper. Still it's quite excellent to hear unreleased tracks like this. The other two are singles, including live favorite 'Born to be Wild'.
Ownership: 1974 Columbia (LP); 2001 Columbia Legacy (CD). Contains insightful liner notes, lyrics, photos, and five bonus tracks.
1978 (first listen); 11/21/12; 7/7/15; 11/26/22 (review)
11/26/22 (new entry)